The fiction of a fixed self

The fiction of a fixed self

November 03, 2026

Buckle up for a long, emotionally driven, hopefully structured (?) in some type of way piece.

Might feel relatable, might not. Let me set the scene.

Current situation: went to the gym this week for the first time in a while.

Background context: been relatively healthy my whole life. Grew up playing sports, working out, played volleyball in college, have always considered myself an active person.

I've never had to really think about being "healthy", it’s just been part of who I am. I'm thankful for that, but lowkey I’ve come to an ~ extremely ~ delusional assumption that I’ll just be healthy forever regardless of what I do.

I’m not dumb. I know I have to do the things. Things like exercise, eating good, and sleeping good all have a crazy significantly positive impact on my happiness and overall health. I've seen a walk turn my entire mood around, I've been pulled out of deep depressions by volleyball, I've gained more clarity on things by sweating than thinking.

I am dumb. Because I can pretty much neglect these things and still identify as a healthy person. How does that make sense? It's like I've earned my right to be classified as a healthy person and I don't have to maintain it.

I'm not judging myself or anyone for missing days at the gym or staying up late. Those things do not = being an unhealthy human. They = being human.

I'm judging myself a littttleee because I've gotten so comfortable thinking of myself as a healthy person, that I don't feel the need to honestly ask myself if I’m living like one.

I give myself some grace because don't think I've been consciously choosing that my health is less of a priority. I didn’t choose to take a break from the gym. Life gets busy and new exciting things take up my time and energy. In my mind, my priorities haven't changed and never will, because I am a healthy person.

You ask me if health is a priority of mine and I’ll look at you crazy, like why are you asking…obviously it is, look at my life, it’s number one.

Nah, you should be the one looking at me crazy, because recently so few of my actions are actually pointing towards it being my #1 priority.

So yeah I've never questioned whether I’m a healthy, athletic, or strong person. I’ve always believed it. And looking back, in some of my party go crazy days…I was kinda the legit opposite of that type of person and even then, I didn’t question it.

Soooo back to my gym sesh realizations.

I was thinking about how crazy it is that I can be so confident in something about myself without doing much, if anything at all, to support it.

Physical health is an easy example. There are tangible things you can point to. You can feel yourself getting stronger...or getting winded walking up the stairs. You can see and feel changes in your body and in the things you're able to physically do.

What about confidence? Independence? Creativity? Authenticity?

What about all the other things you’ve spent years identifying with? The ones that are so ingrained in the way you understand yourself that you don’t question them anymore?

Building an identity is a truly important and crucial part of being human, maybe THE most important part. Building identities through our experiences and living up to those identities give us purpose.

If someone asked me to describe myself I'd say I’m athletic. I’m hardworking. I’m independent. I’m creative. I’m passionate.

Those feel like permanent facts about me that I'd feel confident saying to anyone.

It's scary that they are literally just words. They are literally labels that we've assigned to patterns of actions and behaviors.

At some point, I did things that made me athletic, hardworking, independent, creative, and passionate. I did them so much that they're now part of how I understand myself.

I think that's a really good thing, to be so grounded in who you are, but not if you start seeing these labels as guarantees of who you are and forget about the actions and behaviors that back them up.

That’s where I think certainty starts working against us.

When you become so certain of who you are, it's kind of natural to stop questioning or monitoring your behaviors, challenging your beliefs, or exploring things that feel out of character.

Not only is it natural, it's encouraged. We read books and do all the self help things in order to "know ourselves" and "come into our true selves" but I think we've lost the plot...

It's important to have core beliefs, until we cross the line and start living on autopilot, making decisions based on who we've been instead of what we wanna experience now. Innocently, we think we're being true to ourselves by sticking to things.

If you think you've "arrived", that you've come into your final being, that you truly know all your beliefs support the "right way" of living, you're basically gonna be living in default mode.

That is not only limiting, but actually detrimental to your life. If you're scared you won't achieve what you truly want to experience if you let go of the beliefs that might not serve you anymore...be way more scared of being so certain that they are serving you just because they were before. You can go back.

Holding on so tightly to things is one of our biggest self imposed blockers in life.

(a reframe: it's a win imo, it's rare that blockers that are our control. don't be afraid, take it as a precious gift, it will let you experience something you want and can't usually have.....control lol)


We have complex brains that are constantly collecting evidence of who we are. We pick up on how other people respond to us, what they recognize in us, what they admire, what they compliment us on, what they come to us for. (know your place, know your role, stay in your lane type beat)

We understand ourselves through these interactions, and eventually the way we believe other people see us becomes part of how we see ourselves.

(and I say "believe" because we’re making assumptions about what people think of us anyway. you could try so hard to get someone to think of you a certain way, but they'll always have their own internal biases and life experiences. I promise it'll never align 100% with what you're going for, but you can try! and a side note that I don’t think I have to give but will: obv there are social norms and generally understood ways of treating people that exist for a reason. Be kind, show respect, don't scream at strangers in public…those aren’t personality traits you need to challenge for the sake of being your authentic self. I’m talking about the more subjective parts of how we’re perceived, not suggesting we abandon the basic social agreements that allow us to coexist without absolute chaos. please don't go too crazy then blame me)

CARRYING ON, we learn quick which parts of ourselves get positive responses :) and naturally, we lean into those.

We're not pretending to be someone we’re not. Those reinforced parts of us are real parts of us. Going back to every human's desire for purpose, it feels good to be known for something and to see the value we bring. And because we love to feel good, there is so much comfort in continuing to be that known and valued person.

This is why the questions of "who am I" "am I who I want to be" "am I following my true calling"? can feel so daunting, unnecessary and super disruptive to that good feeling you've spent your life earning and settling into.

Maybe it's common at my age, or maybe it's earlier or later in life, probably different for everyone...but these questions seem like the fuel for a stereotypical mid-life or existential crisis? I don't know.

As much as I love getting deep, it's not that deep. Thinking these questions hold that much weight and should be avoided in order to keep feeling good works against us in two ways.

  1. we stop taking action to support the things we already believe about ourselves because we assume they’ll always be true
  2. we resist exploring anything new because we’re afraid it might contradict the person we’ve spent years becoming

People know me as these things. I know me as these things. If I change anything, I might lose people, opportunities, someone might look at me weird, I might feel like I’m ditching my "true self".

It’s like Kanye putting out 808s & Heartbreak after he already built his career around a certain sound. It was a HUGE departure from what people knew him for. People wanted the Kanye they already knew and they made that clear. But nah he was out exploring something different…and that album went on to influence an entire generation of artists. A lot of artists struggle with this. Follow your curiosity or be "FOR THE PEOPLE"? Pick one. Not both. (This is explored in Rick Rubin's book The Creative Act: A Way of Being. You should def read it.)

As I’ve grown as a woman, I’ve thought about this a lot in terms of femininity (not Kanye, the idea of a shifting identity).

Growing up I loved being able to keep up with the boys. The most basic example: I'd feel GOOD GOOD when I'd step up to the kickball plate in gym, and I'd see the outfielders take some steps back.

You know by now – I was athletic, competitive, funny, independent, blah blah.

I loved and still do love identifying with these things. People have always loved those things about me too.

I leaned into the times I was told I wasn't what someone expected from a girl. I fed off it. I wanted more of that feeling. I leaned into the praise I got for my athletic abilities – especially when they came from a place of "wow, as a GIRL you can do that", inferring that the compliment wouldn't have been given to a guy doing the same exact thing.

In college I definitely leaned into being mysterious...being a cute college party girl but also liking hard rap music and being into the NBA and sneaker culture. I'm not saying any of that was for show, they were just my interests initially. But people consistently and unknowingly pushed me further and further down that path. They made me feel special and cool and unique. Exactly how everyone wants to feel right?

But while I was getting used to living as that version of me, I wasn't giving other parts of me the same opportunities to exist.

Going back to the example of my feminine side...I’d spent so much time pouring into the parts of me that got attention and praise and I wasn’t giving this other side of me the same chance to be seen, appreciated, or even explored!! I wasn’t choosing to be less feminine, I was choosing over and over and over again to be the version of myself I already knew people loved. Without really realizing it, I was suppressing a part of me I wanted to experience more of.

GIVE THE PEOPLE WHAT THEY WANT! (and what they expect)

If you're reading this and actually do know me you might still be surprised by this, by me, Sasha, talking about wanting to explore her feminine side. You're not doing anything wrong by being surprised, but my point is, that reaction gives into my suppression of it more.

You're valid to say it doesn’t fit into the version of Sasha that you know.

I'm not valid for being certain you'll reject her.

I shouldn't let the fear of someone being surprised or the fear of possibly being rejected stop me from evolving. And the people who really do care about me, they wouldn't want me to stop evolving either.

So with a really really deep level of vulnerability (to my 5 readers) I can say I've been waiting for the right time to explore this side of me. I’ve truthfully always assumed that time would come when I grew up and out of my typical ways and I’d just transform into this feminine, womanly being in the blink of an eye, without really doing anything.

The right relationship will bring it out in me, with ease. The right environment where I feel safe and valued will let that side of me SHINE! Then I'll be free!

Can’t wait see you there xoxo!

And that way, the choice to express it would be welcomed and decided for me, it wouldn't be self initiated or forced...because that comes with initial discomfort and awkwardness. It would feel natural, and when people inevitably notice, or ask about why I've changed, I'd have a better, prettier explanation. (obv they would notice bc everyone is so focused on me and not their own lives and insecurities)

LITERALLY WHY am I waiting for SOMEONE or SOMETHING ELSE to give ME permission to be ME?

A dumb (but clever! and deep!) excuse I've used is that I'm scared of abandoning my "true self" because then I won't have the life I want or achieve my goals. The Sasha as I am right now has gotten me sooo many things. So many beautiful, aligned things! (also many fucked up, unaligned things, but those are harder to recall...and for another day)

Truth is that I'm just so fucking scared of ruining or messing with the version of myself that people, including myself, already know and want around.

Even when it's completely authentic, expressing something different than your usual is so vulnerable.

I’m scared to show a side of myself that’s never been THE reason people have been drawn to me. I have proof that being good at volleyball makes people gravitate towards me, makes em wanna be on my team. I have proof that being smart and funny makes people gravitate towards me, it gets me jobs and dates and friends. Embracing my feminine side, being soft and girly? I have 0 proof that it's gotten me anything in life. It’s never been a side of myself that I’ve truly, openly shown.

If I do decide to show it and lean into it now... how do I know it won’t be rejected and I won’t feel embarrassed and hurt and never want to show it again?

It's very contradictory because I’ve always considered myself someone who’s "unapologetically herself". That’s literally part of my identity.

I'm calling myself out – over here saying I'm soooo authentic and sooo vulnerable and an open book...while actively suppressing parts of myself I yearn to be, because I’m worried what people will think?

It’s the same thing as the gym just a lot harder to admit.

In one case I’m relying on who I’ve always been as evidence that I’m still that person. In the other, I’m so attached to who I’ve always been that I’m afraid to be anything else.

I’m baffled thinking about how much of my identity is what I’m choosing vs what I am just maintaining.

I've been choosing, but I think I've been maintainin' since a youngin. I can remember really early on, being able to sense when someone didn't see me the way I saw myself, or the way I wanted them to see me. I remember feeling the intense urge to prove something. Do something about it. It can't just sit like that.

In summer sports camps for example, if I sensed someone doubted me or made a comment about me that didn't align with who I thought I was as an (10 year old) athlete or just a person (kid) I'd feel the immediate urge to remind them that I AM athletic, or carefree, or funny, or cool, or whatever the fuck it is I felt was being questioned.

Livestream of my brain right now, gonna take a slight detour, but I'm finding it interesting that I've always been drawn to working with coaches, therapists, nutritionists, financial planners, doctors, personal trainers, blah blah blah... you can ask my dad (when he's questioned if paying for all these people was worth it/why I couldn't just take initiative on my own), there have been many times I've said yes it's worth it because "I've learned I just do better with a coach or a mentor" and let it be that way. I DO do better. I thought it was a desirable trait, to be coachable, to appreciate being held accountable.

Pause. It can be a good trait, but be honest Sasha.

Have I always needed to sense or hear someone else's perception of me in order to look closer at how I’m showing up?

Have I been relying on other people to set me up to question myself, change something, or explore a different side of who I am?

I can appreciate someone’s guidance...but needing their involvement before I start paying attention to myself? That’s what I think I've fallen into, starting way back when I was a kid.

There is no difference between needing my trainer to be the reason I show up at the gym and needing someone's opinion to make me feel like I’m not living up to the person I believe I am.

As a first step in being true to myself, I'm admitting that it has consistently taken someone else’s involvement to make me stop and look at things or make a change, in many areas of my life. I am grateful for those people and those conversations.

What would happen if no one was watching?

WHAT WOULD HAPPEN IF NO ONE WAS WATCHING…….

That’s terrifying to me because I think a lot would change for me.

I’m scared that I’ve lost the plot. I’ve lost touch with what I actually want because I’ve been so damn worried about being perceived a certain way and I've given up so much of my power to other people. I'm scared I don't trust myself anymore. I'm scared I won't succeed without the weight and pressure of external factors.

I never consciously decided to live this way but I've spent years being rewarded for certain parts of me and I blindly chased the good, addicting feeling of that acceptance.

How long do I let myself keep living and making decisions based on a version of me that I haven’t had the courage to question?


I don't want you to take this as me suggesting that you abandon your identity altogether. You've gotta recognize your strengths, weaknesses, know your core values, and get really fucking clear and honest about what matters to you.

To do that you HAVE to abandon the thought that you already know everything about yourself. You HAVE to abandon the belief that the way you've been living is the only way.

The way you've always thought about things is not how you are supposed think about things for eternity. You sometimes have to let yourself contradict stories you've told yourself your whole life.

You have to experiment, be curious, step into rooms that challenge you, go places that make you examine your "beliefs", ask if the things you say are "just the way I am" are actually serving you anymore.

If we stop checking in with ourselves, if we stop questioning who we are, if we stop questioning if our beliefs are serving us….we risk holding on to an identity that no longer reflects who we’re becoming.

Please, don't wait any longer.

Please don't wait to feel motivated to go to the gym. Don't assume that motivation will come because you're already a "healthy" person.

Don't wait to feel confident to express yourself in a new way.

Don't wait to feel comfortable to let people see the not very "you-like" sides of you.

Don't wait for life to give you the EXACT right circumstances to make you feel like the person you wanna be.

Don't get the order wrong. The feeling you're waiting for is a result of what you're avoiding.

I had to write all that as if I'm giving you advice. If you're new here, welcome, I clearly am not coming from a place of knowing or practicing all that, but writing like that is my way of coping and learning.

(I think that's actually going against what I'm trying to do here. Literally turning my own thoughts into advice for you so I can take it myself. Can’t even have a realization without becoming my own coach and telling myself what to do with it :p)

Let me talk in the first person like I journal. Maybe it'll resonate with you more too.

I'm not gonna feel confident before allowing new sides of myself to be seen. Confidence will come from BEING seen and realizing that hey, I CAN survive other people’s opinions AND be ok with it. And that freedom, even if it makes people run away, feels SO much better than suppression and worry.

Motivation ain't gonna magically appear, at least the lasting kind. I feel the most motivated AFTER going to the gym, AFTER I remember why it matters to me and how good it makes me feel.

Becoming the woman I wanna be is not gonna happen AFTER anything. If I'm just waiting until I feel like her, or until someone makes me feel like her, I. WILL. NEVER. FEEL. LIKE. HER.

GOOD. THINGS. WILL. NEVER. LAND. IF. I. AM. PLACING. THAT. BIG. OF. AN. EXPECTATION. ON. THEM.

I need to give myself the opportunity to experience being her NOW and to discover parts of her that I haven't even imagined yet.

I know the route that focuses on discipline and pressure to "become my best self".

I am more unfamiliar with the route of just actively participating. Without the motivation, without a sign, a signal, SOMETHING from the universe.

I've framed it as being patient. The patience stems from a belief I’ve always had – that things will just work out for me.

My optimism is a great trait of mine and has gotten me through a lot, so now I trust it. I trust it so much that I think things will work out without my active participation.

Evidence of who I've been can’t guarantee who I'm becoming.
Evidence of who I've been can’t guarantee who I'm becoming.
Evidence of who I've been can’t guarantee who I'm becoming.

There is so much out of my control. I can’t keep relying on my past to take care of my future.

I can do everything right and still not get what I want. Take care of my body – still get sick. Work incredibly hard – still fail. Show up authentically – still be rejected.

LIFE.

While I do accept that I can't control all the things, I am done using that acceptance as an excuse to not take responsibility for my life.

I want to be able to trust that things will work out for me without lazily believing they’ll "just work themselves out".

And like I said, it's not just through discipline or examining my habits. I've tried and tried and tried so hard to be this perfectly optimized version of myself, I've made long lists of things I need to change, I've done audits of my time, I'm sitting here with 50+ self-help books jam packed into my bookshelf and a "THIS WILL CHANGE YOUR LIFE" genre podcast queued up on the tv.

Sometimes it feels hopeless because I’ve done everything under the self-help sun.

Sadly, none of it matters much if I’m not paying attention to how I’m actually living.

The root here is more simple than what the modern day self improvement culture (industry $$) wants you to think. It's cheaper than the books, than the luxury gym memberships, than the highly personalized meal plan, than the clean-girl, effortless makeup products, than the pills you can too easily get prescribed.

The root is having awareness of whether the way you're living ACTUALLY reflects the things you say matter to you. Cheaper, but expensive in a different way.

I've spent so much time thinking about how I know who I am, I know exactly who I wanna become, I know what I want for my future, to a tee. I can have it and more, but those things can only be discovered through actually living, not thinking about them.

We treat our identities like something we need to protect, and we treat our future selves like people we’re guaranteed to meet. Neither of those things is fixed. I'm sure you've outgrown certain parts of your identity, maybe without realizing it. I'm sure there are things you used to love that you don’t care about as much now.

There are parts of you and I we haven’t met yet. Let's not be afraid of them.

If we KNOW anything, let's know that there is so much peace and freedom on the other side of it all, let's know that we don’t have to spend the rest of our lives being consistent with versions of ourselves we established forever ago. We will be ok if we explore.

We can change our minds and try things that feel SO completely out of character.

We can surprise people, both those who've known us and those who are strangers. We can surprise ourselves.

Nothing YOU choose to do makes you any less you. If you have even the tiniest thought to want to change or explore a new side of yourself, I’m sorry but that desire is already a real part of you. Stop feeling like you have to prove that it’s consistent with who you’ve always been to give it a chance.

I'm gonna say something that I've spent years reading basically the opposite of: staying true to yourself is the opposite of staying consistent. It's the opposite of staying consistent with who you’ve always been. You need to be open and willing to find out who you are NOW.

LIVE.

DON’T THINK ABOUT LIVING DON’T JUST IMAGINE WHO YOU’LL BECOME DON’T DEPEND ON THAT JUST HAPPENING DON’T WAIT FOR SOMEONE ELSE TO BRING OUT THE PARTS OF YOU YOU’RE TOO AFRAID TO LET OUT

DO THINGS HAVE EXPERIENCES MAKE A DECISION GET IT WRONG CHANGE YOUR MIND BE SEEN IN WAYS YOU’VE NEVER BEEN SEEN

STOP LIVING BY YOUR IMAGINARY RULES!!!! I PROMISE YOU WON'T ABANDON YOUR CORE VALUES AND YOU WILL STILL BE SUCCESSFUL AND HAPPY!


You don’t need to know EXACTLY who you’re becoming and well fuck.....you can’t know even if you tried. You can’t know what might happen tomorrow that will change you forever. If you don't have a kid right now, you can't know how you'll show up as a mom, you can't know how you'll show up once you start that random hobby, you can't know how you'll show up as a coworker at your new job down the road, or as a friend to someone you don't know exists yet. You only know how you've shown up in your experiences so far, so you can hope you show up in new ones well, but you have to be there for those experiences to know. You have to stay curious, not certain, about future you.

I'm gonna virtually hold your hand when I say this.

The person you’ve spent so much time imagining yourself becoming isn’t someone you’re even guaranteed to meet.

Reframe it right now, because that isn't a bad thing, it's a privelege.

Think about it, I think it's safe to say a lot of us have already done things and overcame obstacles we didn't think we would...we've ultimately become people we couldn’t have imagined ourselves being. For better or for worse.

Everything in life is possible….but nothing is a guarantee.

It’s both incredibly uncomfortable and incredibly freeing to know that life won’t be what we think it will be. No matter how much thinking or planning or optimizing we do.

Personally, I know I will be so sad if I look back and realize I was just "trusting" that I’d become who I wanted to be and didn’t live in a way where I could become her.

I'll be so hyped when life works out for me (maybe in the ways I imagine and hope for, maybe in ways I don't understand now). When it does, I'll still want to know I showed up for it, had my own back, and made it happen. I don't want to feel like I had to earn EVERY good thing that came my way, but I want to earn my own respect, and know that because I gave myself the freedom to be who I wanted to be, even when it was new or awkward or uncomfortable or I was uncertain how people would react, things all worked out. I know life will feel 100x sweeter that way. That seems like the kind of true purpose and meaning that we're all searching for.

Feel the fear, do it anyway. Feel the fear, do it anyway. I will give myself limitless opportunities to find out what can happen when I am giving the world my whole self. I will treat myself with kindness, but I will stop making excuses and trusting in old beliefs that don't serve me. I'm clearing out my mind with awareness and intention. My mind can be a place where fear visits, but not where it lives. No more waiting, I am ready to be SASHA, in her beautiful entirety, all parts included.

with love, sm

with love, sm

Hear from me when there's something new

Something went wrong, try again